Rights & Constitution · Live

Should noncitizens be deported for criticizing Israel?

0 votes 8 hrs ago Cast your vote to see the split
The facts

On November 20, 2025, U.S. District Judge William Orrick ruled the Trump administration's policy of deporting noncitizens for pro-Palestinian speech is unconstitutional.

The Supreme Court held in Bridges v. Wixon (1945) that the First Amendment protects noncitizens present in the United States.

Secretary of State Marco Rubio invoked a rarely used 1952 immigration provision allowing deportation of noncitizens whose presence poses 'adverse foreign policy consequences.'

Columbia graduate Mahmoud Khalil, a legal permanent resident, was detained by ICE in March 2025 over his role in campus protests and held for more than three months.

There are roughly 1.1 million international students in the U.S., according to the 2024 Open Doors report from the Institute of International Education.

Cast your vote
Should noncitizens be deported for criticizing Israel?
Live
Live results — voters
Yes — protest visas, get on a plane0%
No — the First Amendment covers everyone0%
See live results from live voters
Cast your vote to unlock America’s reaction
Anonymous · one vote per person
You vs America
You matched the majority.
Your vote lines up with the current national reaction: most voters agree with you.
Your vote
VS
America
How states are voting
Not enough votes yet to show state-level results — check back as more people vote.
Compare with people like you?
Optional: pick how you describe yourself politically to unlock sharper anonymous comparisons.
Full results — votes
Your vote lines up with the current national reaction: most voters agree with you.
Yes — protest visas, get on a plane0%
No — the First Amendment covers everyone0%